The Purposeful Mind – Does a writer need an education?

Writers are an intelligent lot.  The act of thinking, of seeking meaning in ideas, and using language to texture and color these ideas in a written form is an intellectual pastime.  Fed by streams of inspiration and the emotional urge for expression writers seek to inform themselves about the world they see, and in the process of writing inform others of their conclusions.  The two primary rules of the game, that writers must read and writers must write, are the cornerstones of a writer’s education, and by engaging in these two things any writer can advance in her craft without the addition of a formal classroom setting.  This is not to say that there is no benefit to going to school, however, and whether a writer chooses college or self-teaching, there are pros and cons to both options.

The Purposeful Mind

By approaching the craft of writing with single-minded determination, a person intent on mastering the language and mechanics of writing is already equipped with the fundamentals of the craft.  Broad and constant reading, of the kind one might do in college, in addition to those works within the writer’s genre, also increases the writer’s knowledge and development.  Additionally, by collecting a small circle of beta-readers the independent learner gains some of the aspects that a writing workshop would grant in college.  Though absent of many of the formal subjects of a degree program (science, math, history) the self-designed program can benefit this sort of student so long as the individual has massive self-discipline and the confidence to keep going in the face of a void (the void being silence, mostly, and the internal critic who says the writer is slowing falling into the void).

The negatives of independent learning, however, are substantial.  To begin with there is no replacing the guidance of peers and experienced instructors with the one-sided lecture of a book.  In the classroom there is a dialogue, and one’s peers and mentors offer critical insights that might otherwise be missed by independent study.  Furthermore the few peers the writer has are likely to be inexperienced at proper criticism and unable to be of the kind of help a serious writer needs.  And even if the independent learner has assembled the most effective library at their disposal, and gathered around them a number of reasonably qualified peers, there is still the question of confidence – the root of a healthy writer.  The slightest doubt for a writer, in either the structure of their self-made curriculum or in the end-result of their work, can derail even the most persistent artist.  Furthermore, what the classroom offers is a multifaceted competitiveness that cannot be duplicated in private.  By sitting with other students and exposing one’s talents to strangers, the young writer immediately gets a sense of where they rank on a relatively accurate scale.  This awareness can be used as inspiration to improve and to create work worthy of the praise heaped on other students.  The conscientious student of writing is also benefited, whether they are at the top or bottom of the scale, by having access to an instructor who, if worth their salt as a teacher, can give them guidance and criticism that is helpful and encouraging when the internal voices of negativity begin to chant.

The Formal Education

For most of us the days of writing apprenticeship are long gone.  Unless you have the good fortune of being adopted by a professional writer willing to put their energy into making you into the next big thing, you’re better off looking into  the offerings of an accredited college.  The benefits of formal education are indeed many.  The structure of a set schedule and assignment deadlines engenders discipline – one of the keys to success of any kind.  College also exposes one to new ideas, information from areas outside of the individual’s interests and familiarity, thereby rounding out the intellect and knowledge that all writers use for their creative purposes.  College bestows on the active student mentors and peers who help shape the burgeoning writer, and it gives one a place to compose a large portion of their one million words.  Furthermore, it is not necessary to attend an expensive school such as Stanford or Iowa, but because of the nature of the writer’s mind any proper college, including junior and community college, is a good place to start.  It is the writer’s job to observe and learn – the information in most cases is all the same, and any good instructor will be able to teach the important details regardless of the geographic location and name of the school.

Still, the dangers of the college environment, although different, are just as substantial as those of the independent learner.  Academic environments are often stilted, with faculty who are busy trying to publish their own material in order to keep their jobs, or who, having their own favorite heroes of literature, may miss the particular genius of a given student working in a different style.  College writing students may also find themselves ensnared in trying to please their professors.  The pressure to earn a grade forces many students to write what they believe the instructor wants to read, and in some cases a bad instructor will demand it.  In addition, there is often an abundance of time spent reading various published writers, little time dedicated to actual writing, and even less to revision.  Without substantial time to revise students fail to learn the key to creating truly successful works.

To the question “does a writer need an education?” the short answer is “yes.”  Whether through independent study or formal classroom experience, writers must study their craft.  All writers should take courses, even if they choose not to pursue a degree.  The environment, if tempered with an understanding of the pitfalls, will save the student writer time through exposure to new writing styles, story ideas, peer review, mentoring, and by providing structure and discipline.

Advertisements

13 comments on “The Purposeful Mind – Does a writer need an education?

  1. normapadro says:

    I will like to explain another side. I didn’t take any classes in writing. I never liked writing essays in school. I always thought this is not what I like. Then one day I had an idea and that idea turned into reality.

    I began to read a little more. I wasn’t to smart, because I have a learning disability. Teachers weren’t so nice since they wanted me to catch up quickly. I just let things go. I grew up thinking maybe things will be different.

    To make a story shorter. I didn’t need any classes at all. I completed all of my academics in my later years, but always felt that I couldn’t get along with any teachers. I decided to take correspondence courses. This worked out well for me.

    Since I wasn’t sure that any publishing company would publish my work I decided to self publish. It’s worked out well. I never have to worry if anyone likes my work or not. I promised myself that I would never let any institution put me down again.

    I practice writing anytime that I have and apply it to expressing myself in my books. I’m also into photography and publish my photography books as well. If I had listened to other people I would not have gotten anywhere in life. Education can work and may not. I stayed away from schools.

    • emperort says:

      Hi,

      Thank you for sharing your story. As an instructor myself I really appreciate your candid thoughts from a student’s perspective. It is unfortunate that the power a teacher has is sometimes used to hold people back rather than help them advance. But now, despite the obstacles you’ve overcome and shared here, you have found a way to pursue your passion and get your material out there. I wish you continued success and welcome your thoughts anytime.

  2. stuffytales says:

    This post is perfectly timed for me; I decided only last week to supplement my nursing degree with more courses in English. Reading your post reaffirmed my decision, thank you!

  3. Many good points. It just goes to show that there’s no perfect, fool-proof formula for creating a writer. A person could take all of the classes under the sun, but without a lick of talent, he/she won’t succeed. On the other hand, someone who has the potential but lacks guidance won’t likely excel.

    And at the end of the day, I’ve seen both independent learners and the formally educated botch the basics. A diploma doesn’t give you license to misuse commas. 🙂

  4. lpaigewrites says:

    Something I’ve been wondering lately is if it’s necessary for a writer to attend graduate school. I’m already in college and will be receiving my B.A. in English, but I want to become an author and don’t know if graduate school is really essential. I figure that I’ll probably have to have a “real” job in addition to writing my books (at least to start), so maybe a Masters degree really is needed. Could someone shine some light on this for me?

    • emperort says:

      Hi Lee,

      I don’t regret going to grad school one bit. Having a master’s degree made it possible for me to advance in my former career with ease. That being said I do not think you need an MA for a writing career, so it all depends on your reason. I have a BA in Lit and an MA in Comp. My MA has allowed me to teach college writing and humanities classes as well as work well-paying (albeit soul-sucking) administrative jobs. Everything I need to know about writing, however, I really learned by the time I received my bachelor’s and through reading a lot on my own.

  5. jcollyer says:

    I completely agree. I did a BA and an MA at university in Creative Writing and whilst I completely agree formal training is not vital it gave me the precious gifts of structure, deadlines and, as you say, peers and professionals to inform your development. I’m not saying I wouldn’t have reached the point I’m at without those years of dedicated study…but I think it would have taken me a lot longer!

  6. Lanceolot says:

    Thanks for the post. One of my greatest regrets was never to have obtained a formal degree while younger. I doubt it would have made any difference to my successes in the “real non-writing” world, but in hindsight I wish I had done something… anything really. Now, as I reach the big “4 0h crap what I have I done with my life” moment, I am still toying with the idea of doing a creative writing BA through correspondence.

    The thing that is holding me back is that I have interest in learning but no interest in the degree itself and it seems a waste not to pursue it to its ultimate conclusion once started. Correspondence is also lonely and I would be missing out on real interaction with other writers but as an at home Dad I simply do not have the flexibility for regular class schedules.

    I have attended a local writing workshop and enjoyed it thoroughly but I think it was just the tip of the iceberg and left me wanting far more. Now, in an attempt to learn (rather than discover through failure) I attempt to follow exercises in books from Maass, Novakovich and others, while occasionally longing for the camaraderie of like minded individuals baring their souls on paper for all to see.

    So yes, I agree, writers need education – if for no other reason than learning the intricacies of language and writing. Would a higher degree make that much difference to my success as a writer? Ask me in 5 years time – I figure I will be one by then… or flipping burgers at the local diner.

    Hell no.

    • emperort says:

      Lance,

      Are there any writer’s groups nearby? If not, you could start one and I’ll bet, unless you live on a mountain top with no neighbors, that you could get two to five people (an ideal number) to join. This way you could supplement your independent learning with the socializing aspect that is part of the classroom environment.

      Best wishes on your journey.

  7. […] The Purposeful Mind – Does a writer need an education? (tjamesmoore.wordpress.com) […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s